Elkhart County Landlord Guide: The RV Industry Cycle, Goshen’s Amish Economy, and Operating Indiana’s Most Cyclically Volatile Rental Market
Elkhart County offers landlords something unusual among Indiana’s mid-sized counties: genuine boom-and-bust cyclicality that creates both exceptional opportunity and meaningful risk within a single market cycle. No other Indiana county’s rental market swings as dramatically between near-zero vacancy and elevated eviction pressure as Elkhart’s does, and no other county’s rental fundamentals are so completely governed by a single industry. Understanding the recreational vehicle manufacturing cycle — its drivers, its historical pattern, and its leading indicators — is not optional background knowledge for Elkhart County landlords. It is the foundation on which all rental market decisions should rest.
The RV Industry: Boom, Bust, and What It Means for Landlords
The recreational vehicle industry came to Elkhart County through a combination of geographic accident and entrepreneurial momentum that began in the 1930s. Milo Miller built one of the first travel trailers in Elkhart in 1936, and the industry that grew from that beginning eventually consolidated in northern Indiana because of the ready availability of skilled woodworkers, metalworkers, and upholsterers from the region’s furniture and farm equipment manufacturing traditions. By the late 20th century, Elkhart County had achieved a market position so dominant — producing more than 80% of all RVs sold in the United States — that the industry’s national fortunes became the county’s local reality.
The RV industry is acutely sensitive to consumer confidence, gasoline prices, interest rates, and discretionary income. When these factors align favorably — as they did extraordinarily during the 2020–2022 pandemic-era outdoor recreation boom, when Americans fled urban density for road travel and RV sales hit all-time records — Elkhart County’s factories run at full capacity, overtime is abundant, unemployment falls below 3%, and the rental market tightens sharply. Vacancy rates compress, rents rise, and landlords with well-maintained properties in accessible locations can achieve strong returns with minimal marketing effort.
When conditions reverse — as they did in 2008–2009, when Elkhart County’s unemployment rate reached approximately 20%, the highest of any metropolitan area in the United States at the time — the speed and severity of the downturn can be severe. RV manufacturers cut production rapidly and lay off assembly workers first, then suppliers, then service workers. The county’s rental market can shift from near-zero vacancy to elevated eviction pressure within a few months. Landlords who maintained reserves and screened for employment stability during the boom emerge from downturns intact; those who maximized occupancy at any cost during the peak find themselves managing evictions and vacancies simultaneously.
The practical implication for screening: during late-cycle periods when overtime pay has inflated apparent incomes, rely on base wage rates rather than total compensation for income qualification. A production worker making $52,000 base with $18,000 in overtime during a production surge may have qualifying total income of $70,000, but the base wage alone — $52,000 — is the sustainable income that will exist if overtime is cut. Structure deposits accordingly and maintain operating reserves.
Thor Industries and Forest River: The Industry’s Two Giants
Two companies dominate Elkhart County’s RV manufacturing landscape and together employ a substantial portion of the county’s manufacturing workforce. Thor Industries, headquartered in Elkhart and publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange, is the largest RV manufacturer in the world by revenue, operating a portfolio of brands that includes Airstream (arguably the most iconic RV brand in American consumer culture), Jayco, Keystone, and dozens of others. Forest River — founded in Elkhart in 1996 and acquired by Berkshire Hathaway in 2005, making it one of Warren Buffett’s manufacturing holdings — is Thor’s primary competitor and operates its own extensive brand portfolio including Coachmen, Palomino, and work and transit vehicles. These two companies and their extensive supplier networks are the economic engine that powers virtually every aspect of Elkhart County’s rental market.
Airstream’s presence in the county is worth noting separately. The distinctive aluminum-skinned travel trailer, manufactured at Airstream’s Jackson Center, Ohio facility but with significant Elkhart County engineering and management operations, represents the premium end of the RV market and employs a higher-income professional and engineering workforce whose rental profile differs from assembly line workers. Engineers, product managers, and senior manufacturing staff at Thor and Airstream operations are often relocation candidates seeking quality rentals in the $1,200 to $1,800 range.
Goshen: The County Seat’s Dual Economy
Goshen presents a distinctive economic character that differs meaningfully from the manufacturing-dominated profile of Elkhart city. As the county seat, Goshen houses the county government, courts, and administrative functions. But Goshen’s local identity is also shaped by two communities that give it a character unlike any comparable Indiana city: its Amish and Old Order Mennonite neighbors, and its substantial Hispanic community.
The Amish presence in and around Goshen — the result of one of the largest Old Order Amish and Mennonite communities in the United States, centered in northeastern Elkhart County and adjacent LaGrange County — creates a rural economic ecosystem that supports Goshen through agricultural supply, craftwork, and food production businesses that operate on a different cycle than RV manufacturing. Amish and Mennonite workers participate in the conventional rental market at relatively low rates given their community housing traditions, but the presence of this agricultural economy provides a modest countercyclical buffer to Goshen’s RV-dependent income base.
Goshen’s Hispanic community — among the largest proportionally of any Indiana city — has deep roots in the county’s food processing, agricultural, and manufacturing sectors. Goshen’s Main Street has evolved into a culturally vibrant commercial corridor reflecting this community’s economic integration into the local economy. Hispanic workers are a significant segment of the rental market in Goshen, and landlords operating in Goshen should be prepared to work with income documentation that may be non-standard — seasonal employment, cash economy positions, or multi-family income pooling — while applying the same consistent income and habitability standards to all applicants.
Nappanee and the Southern County Market
Nappanee, in southern Elkhart County, occupies a position at the intersection of the county’s RV manufacturing economy and the Amish Country tourism and agricultural economy of the surrounding region. The RV/MH Hall of Fame is located in Elkhart rather than Nappanee, but Nappanee’s Amish Acres — a historic farm and heritage complex — draws tourism traffic that supports a small hospitality and retail economy distinct from the manufacturing corridor to the north. Nappanee’s rental market is smaller and generally less expensive than Elkhart or Goshen, serving a mix of manufacturing workers who prefer a quieter setting and agricultural economy participants.
Elkhart Superior Court and the Eviction Process
All Elkhart County eviction actions file in Elkhart Superior Court, 101 N. Main Street, Goshen, IN 46526, phone (574) 535-6430. The courthouse is in downtown Goshen, the county seat — landlords with properties in the city of Elkhart should note that all eviction filings go to Goshen, approximately 10 miles southwest. Elkhart Superior Court’s eviction docket volume correlates meaningfully with the RV industry cycle: during boom periods, eviction filings are relatively low as employment is near-universal; during downturns, filings increase as layoffs translate into nonpayment. The 10-day pay-or-quit notice may be served personally on the tenant, on a resident of the premises, or by affixing to the premises if no one is found (IC 32-31-1-9). Total timeline in an uncontested Elkhart County eviction commonly runs 25 to 55 days from notice service through sheriff execution of a Writ of Possession.
|
