A Landlord’s Guide to Renting in St. Johns County, Florida
St. Johns County is Florida’s most compelling story of affluent suburban growth. In 2000, the county had roughly 123,000 residents. By 2025 that number has more than doubled to approximately 320,000, driven by one of the most relentless migration patterns in Florida — high-income households from northeastern states, Jacksonville professionals seeking top school districts, and retirees drawn to coastal amenity at somewhat lower prices than southeast Florida. The county consistently ranks as one of the highest-income, best-educated, and lowest-crime counties in Florida, with school performance rankings that attract families from across the Jacksonville metro and beyond. For landlords, this creates a tenant population that is generally among the most financially stable and lowest-risk in northeast Florida.
The Master-Planned Community Dimension
A significant portion of St. Johns County’s rental stock sits within master-planned communities — Nocatee, Palencia, World Golf Village, Beachwalk, and others — that overlay Florida state landlord-tenant law with HOA covenants governing lease approval, tenant conduct, and community rules. Landlords in these communities must be familiar with the specific HOA governing documents for their property. Many HOAs require landlords to submit lease agreements for review, notify the HOA of new tenants, require tenants to acknowledge and comply with community rules, and pay transfer or registration fees at lease commencement. Some HOAs also retain the right to take enforcement action directly against tenants for rule violations, which creates a parallel compliance layer beyond the Chapter 83 landlord-tenant framework. Failing to comply with HOA requirements can result in fines levied against the landlord even when the tenant is the party in violation.
St. Augustine: A Unique Sub-Market
The City of St. Augustine and its immediate surroundings represent a distinct rental sub-market within the county. The historic district’s tourism economy creates demand for both short-term vacation rentals — among the most densely regulated in northeast Florida given the historic preservation overlay — and workforce housing for the significant hospitality employee population. The city has been active in managing STR activity within the historic district, and landlords seeking to operate vacation rentals in St. Augustine should verify current city STR ordinances before operating. Long-term rental properties in and around the historic district command significant premiums due to the lifestyle and walkability they offer.
Filing Evictions in the Seventh Circuit
St. Johns County evictions are filed at the Richard O. Watson Judicial Center, 4010 Lewis Speedway, St. Augustine, FL 32084, phone (904) 819-3600. The Seventh Judicial Circuit assigns five circuit judges and three county court judges to St. Johns County, reflecting the county’s substantial and growing caseload. Despite rapid population growth, St. Johns County’s low eviction rate relative to its population size means the court processes landlord-tenant cases efficiently. The St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office handles service of process at $40 per defendant; contact Judicial Process at (904) 209-1435. Filing fees are approximately $185 for a possession-only complaint.
St. Johns County is, for most Florida landlords, as good as it gets: affluent tenants, strong demand, top school districts that sustain demand year-round, low eviction rates, Florida state law with no local complications, and a growing population that shows no signs of plateauing. The main operational considerations — HOA covenant compliance in master-planned communities, STR licensing in St. Augustine, and flood disclosure for coastal properties — are all manageable with proper preparation. Investors who acquire well-located, well-maintained properties in St. Johns County and screen tenants to the same rigorous standards they would apply in any Florida market consistently report among the most stable rental income and lowest problem-tenancy rates in the state.
|
