A Landlord’s Guide to Renting in Hinsdale County, Colorado
Hinsdale County is, in measurable terms, the most extreme county in Colorado for a landlord to operate in: the smallest permanent population (approximately 750), the lowest population density (0.71 people per square mile — the least of any Colorado county), the highest housing vacancy rate in the state (72%), and a degree of geographic remoteness that the county’s own government describes as unmatched anywhere in the continental United States. The county covers 1,123 square miles of the San Juan Mountains’ most dramatic terrain, 96.5% of which is federal public land managed by the Forest Service and BLM, leaving less than 4% of the county’s area available for private ownership. The only incorporated municipality — Lake City, the county seat — has a permanent population of approximately 400 people living at 8,671 feet elevation in a mountain valley that becomes dramatically more populated in summer and essentially hibernates in winter.
Alferd Packer: Colorado’s Most Famous Cannibal
No account of Hinsdale County is complete without the story of Alferd Packer, whose 1883 trial at the Lake City courthouse produced one of the most quoted — if apocryphal — passages in Colorado judicial history. In February 1874, Packer set out as guide for a party of five prospectors departing the winter camp of Ute leader Ouray near present-day Montrose, bound for the Los Piños Indian Agency near Saguache. Ouray warned them not to attempt the crossing — even the Utes who had lived and hunted in these mountains for generations would not make this journey in winter. The party ignored his advice. Six weeks later, Packer arrived at the agency alone, seemingly well-fed, spending money freely from wallets belonging to the missing men. A search party found the bodies of the five prospectors at the foot of Slumgullion Pass, their flesh stripped. Packer escaped, changed his identity, and was not arrested until nine years later in Wyoming.
Returned to Lake City for trial in 1883, Packer was convicted of murder and sentenced to hang. The Colorado Supreme Court overturned the conviction on a technicality; a second trial resulted in a 40-year sentence that he served in the state penitentiary in Cañon City before being paroled in 1901. The area where his party became lost is still labeled “Cannibal Plateau” on maps; the site where the bodies were found is called Deadman’s Gulch. The CU Boulder student union restaurant is named the Alferd E. Packer Memorial Grill. The Hinsdale County Museum holds what travel publications describe as the largest collection of Packer memorabilia in existence. And Trey Parker — the Colorado native who co-created South Park — made his film-school debut with the 1993 musical comedy “Cannibal! The Musical,” based on the Packer story.
The Slumgullion Earthflow and Lake San Cristobal
Approximately 700 years ago, heavy rains weakened volcanic tuff on the southern flank of Mesa Seco and set in motion one of the most remarkable geological events in Colorado’s recent history: the Slumgullion Earthflow, a slow-motion landslide so massive that when it reached the Lake Fork of the Gunnison River it dammed the entire stream, creating Lake San Cristobal — Colorado’s second largest natural lake. The earthflow is still moving today, at rates as high as 20 feet per year in its active portion, separating pine trees on the hillside and providing geologists with an active natural laboratory for studying mass wasting. Alferd Packer himself, while describing where he had sheltered during the winter of 1874, identified “a large landslide” as a landmark — a description that, over a century later, helped researchers confirm the massacre site’s location. Designated a National Natural Landmark in 1983, the Slumgullion Earthflow is visible from Colorado Highway 149 and accessible from the Windy Point Overlook above Lake City.
The Rental Market: Scarcity, Workforce Need, and Second Homes
The numbers tell a stark story. Of 1,365 housing units in Hinsdale County, 985 are vacant or seasonal. Only 380 units house year-round occupants. The housing market responds to purchasing power from second-home buyers — who comprise roughly three-quarters of the county’s property tax base — rather than to local workforce wages. The result is a county whose essential services — schools, emergency response, county government, local businesses — depend on a year-round resident population that has no viable place to live. The county’s Comprehensive Affordable Housing Plan identifies a gap of 100–112 units needed through 2035, with approximately 32 households at the lowest income levels requiring rental assistance rather than new construction. For landlords who own or acquire year-round rental units in Lake City, this shortage creates a reliable, mission-critical demand that is almost impossible to find elsewhere in Colorado. The tenants who need these units are county employees, school teachers, restaurant and shop workers, guides, and the volunteers who staff the emergency services that make year-round habitation of this remote place possible.
Hinsdale County landlord-tenant matters are governed by CRS Title 38, Article 12. Just-cause eviction (HB 24-1098): 90-day no-fault non-renewal notice required; exemptions for owner-occupied SFH/duplex/triplex, sub-12-month tenancies, STRs, and employer housing. Habitability (SB 24-094): 72-hour begin remedial action; 24-hour for life-safety; pre-arrange emergency contractor relationships — nearest contractors in Gunnison, 55 miles away. Mountain lease essentials: minimum heat 55°F during absences, frozen pipe liability, snow removal, roof load monitoring. STR operators: verify Town of Lake City requirements before advertising; summer-only season with significant winter vacancy. Security deposits: HB 25-1249 caps at 1 month’s rent effective January 1, 2026; return within 30 days. Late fees: 7-day grace; max $50 or 5% past-due rent. Evictions filed in Hinsdale County Combined Court in Lake City (7th Judicial District). Consult a licensed Colorado attorney before taking legal action. Last updated: April 2026.
|
