A Landlord’s Guide to Renting in Aurora County, South Dakota
Aurora County is not a place most people think of when they think about rental property investment in South Dakota. With a total population under 3,000 and a county seat — Plankinton — that has fewer than 800 residents, it is one of the smallest and most rural counties in a state that is already among the least densely populated in the nation. But for landlords who own property here, or who are evaluating opportunities in rural South Dakota, Aurora County presents a set of conditions that are worth understanding on their own terms rather than dismissing as simply “too small to matter.”
The Agricultural Foundation
Everything in Aurora County flows from agriculture. The county’s landscape is rolling prairie, and its economy is built on the production of corn, soybeans, wheat, and cattle. Agriculture accounts for approximately 37% of employment — a figure that is extraordinary by national standards and high even by South Dakota standards. The remaining employment base is distributed across healthcare, retail, education, and government, but even those sectors exist primarily to serve the agricultural community and its families.
For landlords, the agricultural foundation of the economy creates a specific set of conditions. Incomes are relatively strong when commodity prices are favorable — the county’s median household income of approximately $74,130 exceeds the national median — but they are also subject to the cyclical volatility that is inherent in farming. A year of good corn prices and adequate rainfall produces confident, stable tenants. A year of drought, hail, or collapsing commodity markets produces financial stress that ripples through every household and business in the county. This is not a reason to avoid renting in Aurora County, but it is a reason to structure leases, security deposits, and rent collection practices with an awareness that the economic cycle here is tied to forces — weather, global grain markets, federal farm policy — that are fundamentally different from the employment cycles that drive urban rental markets.
Plankinton and the I-90 Corridor
Plankinton is the county seat and the largest community in Aurora County, though “largest” is relative — its population is approximately 780. The town sits directly on Interstate 90, which is the primary east-west highway across South Dakota, connecting Sioux Falls to Rapid City across nearly 400 miles of prairie. Plankinton’s position on I-90 gives it a relevance that its population alone would not support. A small cluster of highway-oriented businesses — gas stations, a convenience store, a motel or two — provides service-sector employment and ensures that Plankinton has a commercial pulse that some comparable-sized communities off the interstate lack.
More importantly for landlords, I-90 connects Plankinton to Mitchell, approximately 20 miles to the east. Mitchell is the seat of Davison County and the nearest community with a full-service hospital (Avera Queen of Peace), a technical college (Mitchell Technical College), significant retail infrastructure, and a broader employment base. Some Aurora County residents commute to Mitchell for work, and a small number of Mitchell-area workers seek more affordable housing in Plankinton. This commuter dynamic is modest in scale — perhaps a handful of households rather than hundreds — but it represents the most reliable non-agricultural source of rental demand in Aurora County. Tenants who work in Mitchell but live in Plankinton for affordability tend to be stable, employed, and motivated by a clear financial calculation.
White Lake and the Southern Half of the County
White Lake is the second community of note in Aurora County, located in the southern part of the county away from the I-90 corridor. With a population of approximately 370, White Lake is even smaller than Plankinton, but it has its own school district (White Lake School District), which provides a small number of stable teaching and administrative positions. White Lake’s economy is almost entirely agricultural, and its rental market is correspondingly minimal — a single rental property vacancy in White Lake might represent a significant percentage of the total available rental stock in the community.
For landlords, White Lake represents an extreme version of the small-market dynamic: when you have a tenant, occupancy is stable and reliable because there is nowhere else for the tenant to go. When a unit is vacant, it may take considerable time to fill because there are very few people actively looking for rental housing. Marketing a rental property in White Lake means relying on word-of-mouth, local bulletin boards, school district job postings, and perhaps a single Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace listing. The traditional urban landlord’s toolkit of online listings, professional photography, and competitive pricing is largely irrelevant here.
The Hunting and Outdoor Recreation Angle
Aurora County is part of South Dakota’s extensive hunting corridor, with multiple federal Waterfowl Production Areas and state game production areas within its borders. South Dakota’s pheasant hunting season is a significant economic event that draws tens of thousands of nonresident hunters to rural counties across the state each fall, and Aurora County participates in that tourism flow. Deer and waterfowl hunting extend the season further.
For landlords with suitable properties, the hunting season creates a potential short-term rental opportunity. Hunters are often willing to pay premium nightly or weekly rates for clean, functional lodging that is close to their hunting areas. A simple house or apartment that might rent for $550 per month on a long-term lease could potentially generate $150 to $250 per night during peak hunting weekends in October and November. However, this opportunity comes with important caveats. Short-term rentals must comply with local zoning regulations, South Dakota’s transient accommodations tax, and any applicable tourism tax obligations. The seasonal window is relatively narrow — primarily October through December — and demand is unpredictable, varying with bird populations, weather, and broader tourism trends. Most Aurora County landlords are better served by the reliability of a 12-month lease with a stable tenant than by the volatility of a seasonal hunting rental strategy.
Tenant Screening in a Small Market
Tenant screening in Aurora County requires adaptation from urban best practices. The standard screening approach — credit check, criminal background, employment verification, rental history — still applies in principle, but the practical execution differs. Many potential tenants in Aurora County are self-employed farmers or agricultural workers whose income does not appear on traditional pay stubs. Verifying income may require reviewing farm income statements, Farm Service Agency (FSA) payment records, crop insurance documentation, or bank statements showing seasonal income patterns. A farmer’s income might arrive in large lump sums after harvest rather than in biweekly paychecks, and a lease structure that accommodates this reality — for example, quarterly rent payments or a harvest-season lump sum — can make sense for both parties in the right situation.
Rental history can also be challenging to verify in a county this small. Many tenants will be coming from informal rental arrangements with family members, farm owners providing worker housing, or situations where the previous landlord is a neighbor or acquaintance. The social proximity of small-community life means that a landlord may already know the prospective tenant, their family, their employment situation, and their reputation in the community. This personal knowledge can supplement formal screening but should not replace it entirely — even in a county where everyone knows everyone, a written lease, a documented security deposit, and a formal screening process protect both parties.
Eviction Procedures and the First Judicial Circuit
Aurora County is part of the First Judicial Circuit, which is administered from Yankton and covers 14 counties across southeastern South Dakota. The Aurora County Courthouse at 401 North Main Street in Plankinton houses the Clerk of Court, who handles eviction filings and other civil matters. The court clerk’s office maintains business hours from 8:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. and 12:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, with a midday closure — a detail that landlords should note when planning courthouse visits.
The eviction process in Aurora County follows the same South Dakota statutory framework that applies statewide. Under the 2024 amendments (SB 89 and SB 90), month-to-month termination now requires only 15 days’ written notice, and the separate Notice to Quit step has been eliminated — landlords proceed directly to Summons and Complaint, with the tenant having five days to answer. For nonpayment of rent, a 3-Day Notice to Quit is required before filing. For lease violations, a 3-Day Notice to Cure or Quit applies. Illegal activity allows immediate filing without prior notice.
In practice, eviction filings in Aurora County are rare. The small docket means that when a case is filed, it may move relatively quickly because the court is not overwhelmed with volume. However, the circuit judges who serve Aurora County also serve the other 13 counties in the First Judicial Circuit, which means hearings may be scheduled around the judge’s circuit travel schedule. Landlords should contact the Clerk of Court at (605) 942-7165 to understand current scheduling timelines before filing.
The Realistic Outlook for Aurora County Landlords
Aurora County is not a market that will generate significant rental income growth, attract institutional investment, or produce the kind of returns that landlords seek in growing urban and suburban markets. It is a place where rental property ownership is a steady, low-drama proposition that works best for landlords who already live in or near the community, who own property that they have acquired through inheritance, family connection, or opportunistic purchase, and who are willing to manage a small number of units with the patience and flexibility that a rural agricultural market demands.
The landlord who thrives in Aurora County is the one who understands that a good tenant in Plankinton or White Lake may stay for five or ten years, paying modest but reliable rent, maintaining the property because they have nowhere else to go and because the social accountability of small-town life discourages neglect. Vacancies, when they occur, may take weeks or months to fill, and rent increases must be calibrated to a market where the alternative for a tenant is not a competing apartment complex but a move to Mitchell or Sioux Falls entirely. The economics are modest. The stress is low. The key is to own the property free and clear, or with very manageable debt, keep maintenance costs controlled, and let the steady cash flow compound over time in a market where competition from other landlords is virtually nonexistent.
Aurora County landlord-tenant matters are governed by SDCL Ch. 43-32 and Ch. 21-16 (as amended by SB 89 and SB 90, effective July 1, 2024). Nonpayment: 3 days late → 3-Day Notice to Quit. Lease violation (curable): 3-Day Notice to Cure or Quit. Illegal activity: file immediately. Month-to-month termination: 15-Day Written Notice. No separate Notice to Quit — Summons & Complaint served directly; tenant has 5 days to answer. Security deposit cap: 1 month’s rent; 2 months if pet. Return: 14 days (no deductions) or 45 days (with itemized deductions). Willful withholding: up to 2x deposit + attorney fees. Late fees in lease; no mandatory grace period. Meth disclosure required if known. Lockout/utility shutoff illegal. No rent control. No just-cause eviction. Court: Aurora County Circuit Court, 1st Judicial Circuit, 401 N Main St, Plankinton, SD 57368; phone (605) 942-7165. Hours Mon–Fri 8am–12pm & 12:30pm–4:30pm CT. Last updated: May 2026.
|
