A Landlord’s Guide to Renting in Benzie County, Michigan
Benzie County punches well above its weight. The smallest county in Michigan by land area — 321 square miles — it nonetheless contains some of the most spectacular scenery in the Midwest: the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore along its Lake Michigan coast, Crystal Lake with its extraordinary turquoise clarity, the Platte River corridor beloved by canoeists and steelhead anglers, and Crystal Mountain, one of Michigan’s most celebrated four-season resorts. These assets produce a real estate market that has appreciated dramatically in the past decade, driven largely by buyers from Chicago, Grand Rapids, and southeastern Michigan seeking second homes, retirement properties, and investment rental properties in one of the most beautiful settings in the Great Lakes region.
The Traverse City Orbit and Its Housing Pressure
Benzie County sits at the southwestern edge of the Traverse City metropolitan statistical area. The city of Traverse City itself is in neighboring Grand Traverse County, but Benzie County is close enough — Beulah is about 25 miles from downtown Traverse City, Frankfort about 35 — that its housing market is significantly influenced by Traverse City’s economy. Traverse City has experienced rapid growth and significant housing cost appreciation over the past decade, pricing many working residents out of Grand Traverse County entirely. Some of those workers have looked to Benzie County as a more affordable alternative while remaining within commuting distance of Traverse City employers. This dynamic has added a year-round workforce rental demand to what was historically a predominantly seasonal market.
The tension between these two demand streams — seasonal vacation rental demand from wealthy out-of-area buyers, and year-round workforce housing demand from local service workers — defines Benzie County’s rental market challenge. The county’s permanent rental stock is thin. Only about 1,035 renter-occupied households exist in the county by census count, a tiny number even for a county of 18,000 people. Meanwhile, the total housing stock is nearly 17,000 units, with a huge proportion sitting vacant for most of the year as seasonal properties. The effective year-round rental vacancy rate in Benzie County is extremely low — far lower than the overall housing vacancy figures suggest — because the seasonal properties simply are not available for year-round tenancy.
The Short-Term Rental Question
The explosion of Airbnb, VRBO, and similar platforms has had a particularly pronounced effect on communities like Benzie County, where natural and recreational assets make properties highly desirable for short-term vacation use. Frankfort’s Lake Michigan waterfront, Crystal Lake properties, Platte River cottages, and properties near the Sleeping Bear Dunes are all in strong demand on short-term rental platforms, and the premium rates achievable on those platforms often dramatically exceed what a year-round lease would generate. This has drawn investment buyers who purchase specifically to operate short-term rentals, which in turn removes properties that might otherwise have served the year-round workforce rental market.
Short-term rental regulation in Benzie County is township-level, not county-level. The county has no unified STR ordinance. Individual townships have varying approaches — some have adopted permit requirements, occupancy limits, or registration systems; others have not. A landlord considering purchasing a Benzie County property for short-term rental use must research the current rules of the specific township where the property is located before completing acquisition, as those rules can change and can significantly affect the property’s permitted uses. Michigan state landlord-tenant law applies to all residential leases of any duration, including short-term tenancies — the security deposit procedures, habitability requirements, and anti-self-help provisions of MCL 554.601 et seq. and MCL 600.5714 et seq. govern every residential rental regardless of whether it is styled as a vacation rental or a traditional year-round tenancy.
Year-Round Tenants: Who They Are and What They Need
The year-round rental tenant pool in Benzie County consists largely of workers in the county’s service, hospitality, retail, healthcare, and education sectors. Crystal Mountain employs a significant seasonal workforce that may rent during the ski and summer seasons. The Frankfort-Elberta and Benzie County Central school districts employ teachers, support staff, and administrators who need stable year-round housing. Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore staff, healthcare workers at the local medical facilities, and county and municipal government employees form a modest but stable year-round tenant base. These workers often face a genuine housing affordability challenge: year-round rents in Benzie County are high relative to the wages available in the county’s service economy, a disparity that has been noted by local workforce development organizations and community planning groups.
For landlords choosing to operate year-round rentals rather than short-term vacation rentals, this affordability dynamic has a practical implication. The most qualified year-round tenants — teachers, healthcare workers, county employees — may have incomes that are modest by absolute standards but are stable and documentable. Income-to-rent ratios that look thin at first glance may actually represent creditworthy tenants for whom the rental constitutes a straightforward budget commitment. Screening criteria calibrated for Benzie County’s wage reality, rather than statewide benchmarks, will yield a more realistic assessment of applicant quality.
Michigan Law in Benzie County: Clean and Simple
There are no local landlord-tenant ordinances in Benzie County. The Michigan Landlord and Tenant Relationships Act (MCL 554.601 et seq.) and the Truth in Renting Act (MCL 554.631 et seq.) are the complete framework. The 85th District Court at 448 Court Place in Beulah handles eviction proceedings for the county. The court’s docket is light — a function of the small permanent population — and uncontested evictions proceed efficiently. Security deposit compliance, inventory checklists, and the 30-day return deadline are the same requirements that apply everywhere in Michigan and must be followed regardless of whether the tenancy is a year-round lease or a short-term occupancy agreement that falls under the residential landlord-tenant statutes.
Benzie County’s median home value has risen to around $276,000, making it one of the pricier markets in northern Michigan and reinforcing the dynamic where entry prices for investment properties have risen faster than rents. Landlords who purchased several years ago are generally well-positioned; those acquiring today should underwrite carefully, using realistic year-round rental income rather than aspirational short-term rental projections, and accounting for the full cost of seasonal property management in a market that is distant from many investors’ home bases.
|
