A Landlord’s Guide to Renting in Mackinac County, Michigan
Mackinac County occupies a uniquely significant position in Michigan’s geography — it sits at the Straits of Mackinac, the four-mile waterway connecting Lake Huron and Lake Michigan, and the county itself has shorelines on both lakes. This makes it one of only two counties in the United States with shorelines on two Great Lakes, a distinction that has shaped over three centuries of history in this corner of the state. St. Ignace, the county seat and only incorporated city, sits at the northern end of the Mackinac Bridge — the 5-mile suspension bridge that has connected the Upper and Lower Peninsulas since 1957. Nearly every driver entering the Upper Peninsula on I-75 passes through St. Ignace, making it literally the gateway to the UP for most visitors and residents.
The Tourism Economy and Seasonal Rental Dynamics
Mackinac County’s economy is dominated by tourism, with Mackinac Island at its center. The island — accessible only by ferry from St. Ignace or Mackinaw City in the Lower Peninsula — is one of Michigan’s most visited destinations, famous for its Victorian architecture, Grand Hotel, fudge shops, and complete prohibition on motor vehicles. Horses and bicycles are the only personal transportation on the island. The island draws over 900,000 visitors annually in peak season, supporting a substantial seasonal hospitality workforce. This workforce creates Mackinac County’s primary rental market pressure: seasonal workers, primarily May through October, who need housing in or near St. Ignace during the tourism season and may or may not remain through winter.
For landlords, this seasonal dynamic is the most important leasing consideration. Seasonal tenants with explicit fixed-term leases are manageable; seasonal tenants who are allowed to hold over without written renewal agreements may establish month-to-month tenancy rights that are more complicated to terminate in the off-season. Hospitality workers’ income is concentrated in summer months, so landlords should verify year-round income capacity before committing to year-round leases with seasonal workers. The most stable year-round tenants in Mackinac County are government employees (county, state, Mackinac Bridge Authority), healthcare workers at the Mackinac Straits Health System, and school district employees.
Native American Community and History
Mackinac County has Michigan’s second-highest proportion of Native American residents at 17.3%, reflecting the county’s longstanding significance as a gathering place for Anishinaabe peoples, particularly the Odawa (Ottawa) and Ojibwe (Chippewa). The Mackinac Bands of Chippewa and Ottawa Indians are state-recognized in St. Ignace. The Sault Tribe of Chippewa Indians, headquartered in Chippewa County, holds two small trust land parcels in Mackinac County — one in St. Ignace Township about 3 miles north of the city, and one in rural Clark Township. Residential landlord-tenant disputes on tribal trust land may fall outside the jurisdiction of the 92nd District Court. The 92nd District Court at the Mackinac County Courthouse, 100 Marley Street, Room 55, St. Ignace, handles all standard landlord-tenant evictions in the county. Security deposit compliance is standard Michigan: 1.5× maximum, 30-day return with itemized list, double damages for noncompliance.
|
