Rich County Utah Landlord-Tenant Law: Guide for Bear Lake and Randolph Area Rental Property Owners
Rich County sits in Utah’s northeastern corner, tucked against the Idaho and Wyoming borders in a high-elevation landscape of mountains, valleys, and the remarkable Bear Lake. With a population of approximately 2,400, Rich County is among Utah’s least populated, yet it contains one of the state’s most recognizable recreational destinations — Bear Lake, a 109-square-mile freshwater lake known for its vivid turquoise-blue color, caused by calcium carbonate suspended in the water. The lake straddles the Utah-Idaho border, with the Utah shore anchored by Garden City, a small community that transforms into a bustling vacation destination every summer. The Bear Lake raspberry shake is something of a regional culinary institution, and the area draws visitors from the Wasatch Front, Wyoming, and Idaho for boating, fishing, swimming, and the annual Raspberry Days festival.
For landlords, Rich County is essentially two different markets. The Bear Lake shoreline, particularly Garden City and Laketown, operates as a vacation real estate and short-term rental market where property values are high, STR income potential is strong during the summer season, and long-term rental inventory is nearly nonexistent. The inland communities of Randolph, Woodruff, and their surrounding ranch lands operate as a traditional rural agricultural community where housing is owner-occupied or informally rented to ranch workers at modest prices. The two markets barely intersect.
Utah Law in Rich County
All residential rental activity in Rich County is governed by Utah’s statewide landlord-tenant framework. The Fit Premises Act (Utah Code §§ 57-22-1 through 57-22-7) requires landlords to maintain habitable conditions. Rich County sits at elevations of 6,000 feet and above, and the Bear Lake basin specifically is known for harsh winters with significant snowfall, strong winds, and cold temperatures that can plunge well below zero Fahrenheit. Heating systems and proper weatherproofing are essential legal obligations for Rich County landlords, not optional amenities. Landlords should service heating equipment annually and document that service.
Security deposits carry no statutory cap in Utah. The 30-day return deadline under Utah Code § 57-17-3 applies strictly. Evictions in Rich County are filed in the First District Court at 20 South Main Street, Randolph, UT 84064, reachable at (435) 793-2415. As a rural county courthouse, landlords should contact the clerk directly to confirm current hearing schedules and procedures before filing.
For landlords near Bear Lake who are considering short-term rental conversions, Rich County has enacted STR-related regulations in response to the rapid growth of vacation rentals along the lake. Verify current permit requirements and zoning restrictions directly with Rich County before listing any property on Airbnb, VRBO, or similar platforms. The regulatory landscape for STRs in Rich County continues to evolve as the community grapples with balancing tourism economics against the needs of year-round residents.
This guide is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Landlord-tenant law is subject to change. Consult a licensed Utah attorney or contact the First District Court in Randolph at (435) 793-2415 for guidance specific to your situation. Last updated: April 2026.
|